What many considered obvious fouls were examined and dismissed by VAR, leading to clear frustration among United’s players, coaching staff and supporters, and a wave of criticism from supporters and commentators.
The initial situation arose when a United footballer fell in the Chelsea boxes and was apparently brought down by a Chelsea opponent, in what appeared to be a significant disruption to play. As supporters kept their hopes alive, VAR conducted a review of the game, only to uphold the on-field decision to continue play.
The denial of a penalty at Old Trafford sparked surprise, with both supporters and players expressing discontent at the perceived unfairness.
Social media platforms were quickly bombarded with posts from supporters questioning the consistency of VAR, particularly in light of recent penalties in comparable situations within the league.
Just minutes later, United were in the midst of another controversial VAR decision. In a quick attack, another United player was brought into the box and again there was significant contact, which many considered justified. For the second time in the match, VAR denied the spot kick, leading to play continuing.
The double denial added to the frustration felt by United supporters, with some suggesting their team were treated unfairly at crucial stages of the game.
Reactions from supporters and critics have proved swift and passionate, with former players and analysts taking to social media and post-match broadcasts to voice their disapproval. One commentator commented, “If those challenges aren’t penalties, then it’s unclear what is.”
VAR’s responsibility is to ensure fair play, yet tonight it has simply created inconsistency. There have been calls from numerous individuals for the Premier League to address the perceived lack of clarity and transparency in VAR decisions, particularly in situations that could have a direct impact on the outcome of a match.
The frustration extended beyond the supporters and was seen by the Manchester United manager protesting from the sidelines. In his post-match comments he expressed dissatisfaction with the decision-making, saying, “We expect fairness, particularly at crucial moments, and tonight it felt like we were denied.” United players were also affected by the calls, with some clearly frustrated as they arrived for the dressing room at half-time.
This latest VAR controversy has provoked profound debates within the football community about the effectiveness and reliability of the technology at the top level of football. While While While While While While While While While