Manchester United endured a dismal evening at Old Trafford as they suffered their sixth defeat in a single calendar month, matching an unwelcome club record. Newcastle United dominated the game, securing a convincing 2-0 win. The Magpies asserted their control early, with Alexander Isak and Joelinton scoring within the opening 20 minutes, leaving the home side reeling.
United’s manager, Ruben Amorim, attempted to halt the downward spiral by making a tactical adjustment in the first half. Joshua Zirkzee, who had been positioned on the left wing, was substituted for Kobbie Mainoo, a move that aimed to strengthen United’s midfield. However, this decision was met with sarcastic applause from sections of the Old Trafford crowd, which former United captain Gary Neville condemned during his live commentary.
The reaction from the crowd seemed to deeply affect Zirkzee, who appeared visibly shaken as he left the pitch. After donning his jacket, he briefly headed towards the tunnel before returning to the bench. According to a Sky Germany journalist stationed near the tunnel, the Dutch forward looked emotional, with “tears in his eyes,” following the public humiliation he endured.
Speaking after the game, Amorim addressed the controversial substitution. While acknowledging the difficulty of the decision, he defended the move, emphasizing the importance of balancing individual and team priorities. “Josh was having a tough time, and we needed to make adjustments to improve our midfield,” Amorim explained. “It was not an easy call, but I spoke with him afterward to ensure he understood my reasoning. He’s a strong individual, and we’ll continue to support him.”
Neville was quick to criticize the fans’ behavior, labeling the sarcastic cheers as “brutal.” He expressed empathy for Zirkzee, highlighting the emotional toll such an incident can take on a player. “I feel for Joshua Zirkzee,” Neville stated. “Yes, he’s a professional earning a significant salary, but he’s also a human being.
To be jeered off by your own supporters is incredibly harsh. In all my years at Old Trafford, I’ve rarely witnessed anything like this.” While acknowledging Zirkzee’s lackluster performance, Neville also pointed out that the team collectively failed to meet expectations.
Zirkzee, who joined United on a five-year contract during the summer transfer window, has struggled to make a significant impact. With just four goals in 25 appearances across all competitions, speculation has already emerged about his future at the club, fueling rumors of a potential departure.