Ruben Amorim has spoken out following Manchester United’s 2-0 defeat to Newcastle United at Old Trafford, placing forward Joshua Zirkzee at the center of his criticism. The loss, which marked United’s fourth consecutive defeat, has intensified scrutiny on the club’s performances and the unity within the squad.
Amorim expressed frustration with Zirkzee’s lack of impact during the match, going so far as to suggest the player might benefit from leaving the club. “It’s disappointing; he doesn’t show the confidence needed, and I can’t work with a player like that. Perhaps he should consider finding a new team,” Amorim stated. His blunt remarks have sparked debate among fans and pundits alike, raising questions about the manager’s approach and Zirkzee’s future.
The match itself was a dismal affair for United. Newcastle took control early, with Alexander Isak and Joelinton scoring within the first 20 minutes. Zirkzee, deployed in an advanced midfield role behind striker Rasmus Højlund, struggled throughout. He completed only 12 accurate passes and failed to provide any creative spark. By the 33rd minute, Amorim substituted him, a decision met with applause from frustrated home supporters.
Zirkzee, who joined United in July 2024 for £36.5 million from Bologna, had initially shown promise, netting the winning goal on his debut against Fulham. However, his performances have since declined, with only three goals in 18 Premier League appearances. His lack of form has drawn heavy criticism, and Amorim’s comments have fueled speculation about his potential departure during the upcoming January transfer window.
Fans are increasingly questioning how a player once considered a promising acquisition has fallen out of favor so quickly. Meanwhile, Amorim’s remarks have raised concerns about potential divisions within the squad, with critics arguing that such public criticism could exacerbate internal tensions.
Football pundits have weighed in on the controversy. Former Manchester United defender Gary Neville described Amorim’s comments as “harsh,” acknowledging the frustration but cautioning against further damaging the player’s morale. Neville pointed out that the public nature of the critique reflects the growing dissatisfaction at Old Trafford, where poor results have left supporters deeply disappointed.
As the January transfer window approaches, speculation about Zirkzee’s next move is intensifying. A change of scenery could offer him the opportunity to rebuild his confidence and career. For Manchester United, however, this incident underscores a broader set of challenges. With their season unraveling, the club must address on-field struggles and internal discord to restore stability and optimism.