Antony’s declining influence at Manchester United has sparked discussions, with recent insights highlighting the roles played by both Erik ten Hag and Rúben Amorim in limiting his effectiveness. A source from Real Betis has shed light on how the Brazilian winger was tactically neutralized, offering a deeper understanding of the strategies that have contributed to his struggles.
Rúben Amorim, known for his emphasis on defensive structure, reportedly identified and exploited Antony’s weaknesses when Sporting CP faced him in European competitions. His tactical blueprint focused on restricting Antony’s space, forcing him into tight areas where he had limited room to maneuver, and cutting off his preferred passing lanes.
By congesting the wide areas and directing him onto his less dominant right foot, Amorim managed to neutralize the winger’s ability to drive forward and create goal-scoring opportunities. This systematic approach rendered Antony predictable, depriving him of the freedom and fluidity that previously allowed him to flourish.
However, Amorim was not the only coach who inadvertently contributed to Antony’s struggles. Erik ten Hag, who worked closely with the Brazilian during their time at Ajax, also played a part, though unintentionally. Instead of making tactical adjustments to maximize Antony’s strengths, Ten Hag’s approach at Manchester United has seemingly left the winger in a one-dimensional role.
Antony’s tendency to cut inside onto his stronger left foot has become a recurring pattern, making him easier to defend against. Without sufficient tactical variation in his movements, opponents have found it simpler to anticipate his next move and shut down his attacking influence.
Another factor limiting Antony’s impact is the lack of overlapping full-backs who could provide width and additional passing options. This tactical limitation has often left the Brazilian isolated, forcing him into one-on-one situations where defenders can predict his movements and counter him effectively. Unlike at Ajax, where he thrived in a system that allowed him to interchange positions and combine with teammates, Manchester United’s setup has made him more predictable and easier to contain.
The key question now is whether Antony can adapt and rediscover his attacking prowess. To overcome the defensive strategies that have stifled his influence, he may need to refine his weaker right foot, enhance his decision-making under pressure, and explore alternative roles within the team. As Manchester United undergoes tactical adjustments, Antony’s ability to evolve and diversify his approach could be crucial in determining his long-term future at the club. Whether he can reinvent himself and regain his attacking edge remains to be seen, but his response to these challenges will ultimately shape his career trajectory.
