A former Manchester United legend has cautioned the club against appointing Rúben Amorim as their next manager, arguing that United should pursue a coach with a proven track record to restore them to dominance in both English and European football. While Amorim has enjoyed success with Sporting CP—leading them to a Primeira Liga title in the 2020-21 season and developing young talent—there are concerns about whether he is the right fit for a club of United’s stature.
One of the biggest red flags, according to critics, is that Liverpool, who initially considered Amorim as a successor to Jürgen Klopp, ultimately opted against hiring him. This decision raises questions about his readiness for the Premier League. If a club as ambitious and well-structured as Liverpool hesitated to take a chance on him, should Manchester United be willing to take such a gamble?
The strong recommendation from the former United icon is that the club must secure a world-class manager—someone with a history of success at the highest level—to keep pace with Europe’s elite teams. Among the leading candidates suggested are Carlo Ancelotti, a highly decorated manager who has won league titles in multiple countries and is known for his ability to manage star players while adapting tactically; Zinedine Zidane, a three-time Champions League-winning coach with Real Madrid, respected for his leadership and ability to command authority in the dressing room; and Eddie Howe, who has transformed Newcastle United into a competitive force in the Premier League, earning praise for his tactical intelligence and squad-building expertise.
Given Manchester United’s vast resources and global influence, there is little reason for the club to settle for anything less than a top-tier managerial appointment. Over the past decade, United has experienced inconsistent performances and a series of disappointing managerial decisions, leading to prolonged struggles.
Choosing another unproven coach could result in continued underachievement, making this upcoming decision one of the most critical in the club’s recent history. The former United star has emphasized that getting this appointment right is essential to avoid further setbacks and to position the club for long-term success.
However, it is important to clarify that there are no verified reports of a Manchester United legend making such comments about Rúben Amorim. Additionally, Erik ten Hag remains in charge at Old Trafford, with the club recently reviewing the season and opting to retain him, even offering him a contract extension.
Amorim continues to manage Sporting CP, and there have been no official approaches from Manchester United regarding his potential appointment. Furthermore, the three suggested candidates—Ancelotti, Zidane, and Howe—are all currently committed to their respective clubs, making an immediate move to United highly unlikely.
