Arsenal captain Martin Ødegaard has long been seen as the face of the club’s resurgence under Mikel Arteta since being handed the armband in 2022.
Lauded for his composure, football intelligence, and tactical discipline, the Norwegian midfielder quickly earned the trust of fans and management alike.
However, as the 2024/25 season enters a critical phase, concerns are beginning to surface about his current form and leadership capabilities.
Last season, Ødegaard was instrumental in Arsenal’s push for the Premier League title, consistently delivering standout performances marked by crucial goals, assists, and control in midfield.
His influence extended beyond statistics—he dictated play, brought balance to the team, and led with quiet authority.
His leadership, though not vocal or aggressive, was based on setting an example through professionalism and performance.
But this season has told a different story. Arsenal’s form has dipped, and with the club falling out of the title race, frustration among fans is growing.
The recent confirmation of Liverpool as Premier League champions has intensified scrutiny on Arsenal’s shortcomings, and as captain, Ødegaard has found himself at the center of that criticism.
The 1-0 loss to Paris Saint-Germain in the first leg of the Champions League semi-final at the Emirates appears to have been a tipping point.
In a match many hoped would showcase Arsenal’s growth on the European stage, the team looked lackluster—and Ødegaard, in particular, failed to stamp his authority on the game.
Disappointed fans began questioning whether the team needs a different type of leader to navigate high-pressure moments.
According to Football Insider, some supporters are calling for a change in captaincy, suggesting that Ødegaard’s quiet demeanor might not be what the team needs when the stakes are highest.
Names like Declan Rice and Gabriel Magalhães have emerged as alternatives—players seen as more visibly vocal and commanding on the pitch.
Still, the debate has polarized opinions online.
Many still support Ødegaard, pointing to his calmness, intelligence, and consistency as key leadership traits.
It’s essential to remember that Ødegaard’s style is not built on aggressive motivation but rather on thoughtful play and composure.
Yet, in high-stakes matches, fans often crave more emotional leadership—a captain who can inspire the squad with energy and urgency.
That kind of fire seemed absent against PSG, leading some to question whether Ødegaard has what it takes to rally the team in critical moments.
Despite the noise, Ødegaard has maintained his professionalism.
He hasn’t addressed the criticism publicly but has continued to focus on preparation ahead of the decisive second leg in Paris.
That match now represents a pivotal moment in his tenure. A strong showing could silence critics and reinforce Arteta’s faith in him.
Arteta has shown no indication of making a change.
After the PSG defeat, he defended his captain, stating that “we win and lose as a team” and praising Ødegaard’s character and commitment.
Still, if Arsenal fail to progress to the Champions League final and the performances don’t improve, calls for a new captain could grow louder.
Ultimately, this is a defining test for Ødegaard—not just as a player, but as a leader.
At 26, he still has time on his side and has already shown maturity and class.
What happens next could shape his legacy at Arsenal.
Whether he emerges from this period stronger or yields to the pressure remains to be seen.
But it’s clear: the coming weeks will be crucial for both Ødegaard and the club’s ambitions.
