The ongoing fallout between Manchester United manager Rúben Amorim and winger Alejandro Garnacho has now reached a boiling point, pushing the talented Argentine closer to a dramatic exit from Old Trafford.
According to sources within the club as of July 1, 2025, Amorim has reportedly branded Garnacho a “bad influence”, citing his off-field behavior and public conduct as destabilizing to the squad.
The tension between the two has culminated in Garnacho’s £50 million switch to Arsenal, a move that has shocked and divided the Manchester United fanbase.
Many supporters have taken to social media to express their disappointment, with some blaming Amorim for being too rigid, while others support his no-nonsense approach.
The dispute can be traced back to the aftermath of United’s Europa League final loss to Tottenham Hotspur in May. Garnacho, clearly frustrated, took to social media and referred to the season as “s***.”
That post set off alarms within the club, but the real controversy erupted in June, when the 20-year-old shared a vacation photo wearing an Aston Villa jersey with Marcus Rashford’s name on the back.
This act was viewed by Amorim as a blatant show of disrespect, especially given Rashford’s own exit earlier in the summer.
In response, the Portuguese coach fined Garnacho and removed him from the club’s preseason travel plans.
Amorim reportedly felt that Garnacho’s attitude was incompatible with the disciplined culture he is trying to build at United.
Despite earlier signs of improvement in the player’s professionalism, insiders claim his recent behavior reversed any progress.
Amorim has taken a firm stance, also green-lighting the exits of other problematic figures like Rashford, Jadon Sancho, and Antony.
Statistically, Garnacho had a solid 2024/25 campaign, contributing 11 goals and 10 assists across 58 appearances.
His acrobatic strike against Everton even won him the Puskás Award, reminding fans of his immense potential.
However, Amorim reportedly grew tired of his erratic displays and perceived immaturity.
The summer overhaul at United has been massive, with the club spending nearly £360 million on top signings including Harry Kane, Viktor Gyökeres, Bryan Mbeumo, and Diego Leon.
Garnacho’s departure helped finance this transformation, but many supporters are still reeling from losing a beloved academy graduate.
While some back Amorim’s hardline stance, others feel the club has let go of a generational talent too soon.
Adding to the tension, Amorim is reportedly frustrated with the board’s pursuit of Eberechi Eze, a move made without his full approval.
As Garnacho prepares to begin a new chapter under Mikel Arteta at Arsenal, United faces growing questions about internal alignment and whether Amorim’s strict methods will unify or divide the squad further.
This saga marks a turning point for Manchester United, as the club walks a fine line between rebuilding with discipline and potentially alienating its future stars.
